Sep 03.

Stefan Molyneux

0 comment

A war to be proud of..?

(a response to Christopher Hitchens’s artcle – http://www.canada.com/national/nationalpost/news/issuesideas/story.html?id=88b9506a-c155-4dd3-829b-bd8b43a936b2)

The reality of war is so often obscured by abstractions. Let us take a closer look at Mr. Hitchens’s obfuscating language and get to the meat of the matter.

War is organized murder, pure and simple, just as dictatorship is. Mr. Hitchens can proclaim that the murder of tens of thousands of Iraqis – who had done nothing to threaten the United States – was worth it, but he does not explain just how he achieved the exalted position of determining the value of other men’s lives. A man living under a dictatorship may choose to risk his life resisting it – or he may choose to live with his circumstances. We know for certain that the vast majority of Iraqis preferred to live under Saddam rather than risk their lives resisting him – since before the US invasion, that is exactly what they did. The tens of thousands who have been killed for the sake of ‘regime change’ would have far preferred to live, and that is not a decision that can be made for them.

Mr. Hitchens also says: “Anyone with the smallest knowledge of Iraq knows that its society and infrastructure and institutions have been appallingly maimed and beggared by three decades of war and fascism…” This is of course true. What is pointedly not mentioned is the fact that Saddam Hussein was armed and helped into power by the United States government in 1963. Or that the majority of his war crimes were committed while he was receiving support from the US government. Or that the US sanctions against Iraq – which did nothing to topple Hussein – caused the deaths of hundreds of thousands of Iraqis, mostly children. Imagine a neighbourhood where people suffer terribly because the local police arm and aid the Mafia – are these same people then expected to support the police when policy changes, and policemen kick down doors and spray random bullets in the hunt for their former friends?

What is also conspicuously absent from all justifications for the invasion of Iraq is that the war was justified solely on the grounds that Iraq had WMDs and was going to use them against America. (The mere possession of WMDs – and support of terrorism – is not enough, since the US supports – among many such states – Saudi Arabia and Pakistan.) Changing justifications after the fact does not turn falsehood into truth. The invasion of Iraq was justified by the threat that Iraq posed to America. Iraq, in fact, posed no threat to America. Thus the war is unjustified. It really is as simple as that.

Last but not least, I am utterly out of patience with armchair philosophers who sit in air-conditioned offices thousands of miles from the terror and slaughter and write articles about the benefits of war. Mr. Hitchens informs us that invading Iraq was a responsibility “that no decent person could shirk”. I am sure that we can then assume that, as a decent person, he is going to Iraq to help with the fighting. No? Is he too old? Well, then he must be lecturing his own sons and daughters that they must go and fight for Fallujah, or be condemned as indecent. No? Well, perhaps he has no children. Ah, then he must be selling everything he owns in order to send gifts and guns to the soldiers. Is he doing any or all of these things? If not, then he should take a long look in the mirror and ask himself exactly why others must murder and die for the sake of his beliefs. If you are not willing to lay down your own life – or the lives of your children – then you have no right to demand that others do so.

Stefan Molynuex, is the host of Freedomain Radio (www.freedomainradio.com), the most popular philosophy site on the Internet, and a “Top 10” Finalist in the 2007-2010 Podcast Awards.

Sign up for the Freedomain Newsletter to receive previews of upcoming shows, exclusive presentations, invitations to private call in shows and much more!

Please enter a valid email address
That address is already in use
The security code entered was incorrect
Thanks for signing up